Contractors on Virginia public projects likely are aware that their responsibility to correct defective construction can be unending. By Virginia statute (Code §8.01-231), there is no statute of limitations that applies against the Commonwealth. While private parties are barred from bringing lawsuits after a certain period of time, no such bar applies to the Commonwealth.
This month the Supreme Court of Virginia made clear in Hensel Phelps Construction v. Thompson Masonry Contractor that incorporating the prime contract on a state project into lower tier subcontracts is not enough to also expose the lower-tier subcontractors to endless liability. The endless period isn’t created by the prime contract, but by the statute.
Fourteen years after finishing a job at Virginia Tech, the Commonwealth sued Hensel Phelps for defective work. Hensel Phelps settled and then sought to recover from its subs. Hensel Phelps asserted defective work claims, for which the time period to sue began when the breach (i.e. defective work) occurred. The trial court dismissed the lawsuit, finding that as between Hensel Phelps and the subs, the statute of limitations for breach of contracts had expired and barred the recovery claims. The Supreme Court agreed.
Hensel Phelps may have succeeded in pursuing claims against the subs had the indemnity provisions of its subcontracts been enforceable. Claims for indemnity do not begin to run until the indemnitee pays the obligation for which it is owed indemnity. Under that theory, the indemnity claim didn’t arise until Hensel Phelps paid the settlement.
Unfortunately for Hensel Phelps, the indemnity clauses in its subcontracts were too broad. The clauses attempted to indemnify Hensel Phelps even for its own negligence: running afoul of Virginia law holding indemnification void as against public policy where it indemnifies a party against liability for his own negligence.
This case gives rise to several important lessons learned:
Be aware that public projects can carry endless liability;
Make sure your indemnity clauses are drafted so as to be enforceable under all law;
When working on public projects, carefully review whether your contract lines up with the recovery rights you seek to preserve.For instance, general contractors could require subcontractors to expressly waive any rights under the statute of limitations.
Consider including language explaining the rights among the parties in the event of future recovery actions by a public owner, such as delayed accrual for indemnity claims or affirmative rights to assert breaches long after a statute of limitations has expired.
As president of Hirschler and head of the firm's litigation section, Courtney knows how to lead people and projects to a successful outcome.
Leveraging deep experience in the construction industry, Courtney advises public and ...
Kelly’s practice focuses on construction law, commercial and product liability law, with an emphasis on dispute resolution—including mediation, arbitration, jury and bench trials in state and federal court. She routinely ...
Nate fully engages in each case and shoulders his clients’ needs. Communication, efficiency and careful judgment define his practice. In every case, he investigates competing claims to thoroughly understand their strengths ...
A professional engineer (P.E.) and an experienced lawyer, Webb began practicing at Hirschler Fleischer following four years of work as a consulting engineer. His multidisciplinary practice focuses on general business and ...
SubscribeSubscribe to Hirschler by Email
- Changes to Mechanic’s Lien Law Effective July 1!
- Virginia General Assembly: Construction Bills To Watch- Part 2
- Courtney Paulk and Kelly Bundy Discuss “Unpreventable Employee Misconduct” Defense in Article for Construction Executive
- Five Licensure Issues All Virginia Contractors Should Consider
- New Trump Executive Order Encourages Buy American Preferences in Infrastructure Projects
- Five Issues all Subcontractors and Suppliers on Federal Projects Should Consider
- Litigation. Arbitration. Mediation. What is the Difference and Who Should Care?
- Courtney Paulk to Participate in University of Richmond - Robins School of Business's C-Suite Conversations
- Virginia General Assembly Opens Session Today: Construction Bills To Watch
- Construction Year in Review: 2018 Trends and What To Expect in the Year Ahead
- Mechanic's Liens
- Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA)
- Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation (DPOR)
- Dispute Resolution
- Government Contracts
- Miller Act
- Workforce Development
- Virginia Employment Commission (VEC)
- Virginia Workers' Compensation Commission
- Uniform Statewide Building Code
- Change Orders
- Little Miller Act
- June 2019
- April 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016