Many design and construction contracts and subcontracts contain a “waiver of subrogation” provision in the contract’s “Insurance Requirements” section. This type of provision is included to prevent an insurance company, that has paid for a loss, from suing another party involved with the project that may have actually caused the loss. But what exactly is “subrogation” and what does it mean to “waive” subrogation rights?
Subrogation is the legal concept that allows an insurance company which has paid for a loss, to “step into the shoes” of (in other words become “subrogated” to the rights of) its insured following a loss and then sue a party that may have been responsible for the loss. Here’s an example:
An owner engages a general contractor to build a 20-story office building in downtown Lynchburg. The contract between the owner and the general contractor contains a waiver of subrogation clause stating that, to the extent that any damage to the project is covered by insurance (either the owner’s insurance or the general contractor's insurance), the owner and general contractor waive all rights against each other regarding such damage. The general contractor, in turn, enters into a subcontract with a subcontractor that contains a similar waiver of subrogation provision. Later, in the midst of the construction project, an employee of the subcontractor negligently starts a fire that destroys the unfinished high-rise, causing a $5M loss for the owner.
If the owner has a builder’s risk policy in place which permits the insured (owner) to waive subrogation rights in writing prior to a loss, then the owner’s builder's risk insurer will be obligated to pay the $5M loss but will not be able to sue the general contractor or the negligent subcontractor to recover the $5M that it paid on the loss. The risk of loss is not passed on to anyone else and stays with the insurance company.
This is the result that most parties to a construction project want to see – the insurance company, which has collected significant premiums, shoulders the risk of the loss without being able to pass the risk of loss on to anyone else. Importantly, however, it was a provision in the owner’s builder’s risk policy – specifically, the provision that permitted the insured to waive the insurance company's subrogation rights - that allowed this result to occur.
One practical benefit to the waiver of subrogation is that the insured avoids costly litigation that may ensue from counterclaims or cross-claims filed after the insurer pursues the negligent party.
The lesson to be learned: Whenever a contract requires you to waive subrogation rights, check with your insurance consultant before signing the contract to ensure that, by waiving an insurer’s subrogation rights, you are not invalidating or compromising your own insurance coverage. This is a real risk and one that owners and contractors can avoid with a single phone call.
As president of Hirschler and head of the firm's litigation section, Courtney knows how to lead people and projects to a successful outcome.
Leveraging deep experience in the construction industry, Courtney advises public and ...
Kelly’s practice focuses on construction law, commercial and product liability law, with an emphasis on dispute resolution—including mediation, arbitration, jury and bench trials in state and federal court. She routinely ...
Nate fully engages in each case and shoulders his clients’ needs. Communication, efficiency and careful judgment define his practice. In every case, he investigates competing claims to thoroughly understand their strengths ...
A professional engineer (P.E.) and an experienced lawyer, Webb began practicing at Hirschler Fleischer following four years of work as a consulting engineer. His multidisciplinary practice focuses on general business and ...
SubscribeSubscribe to Hirschler by Email
- General Assembly Has Killed Right to Work Repeal Bills
- Virginia Statute of Limitations Bill Advances Through General Assembly
- House Subcommittee Passes Bill Establishing Limitations Period Against The Commonwealth
- Are You a Joint Employer? The DOL’s New Test Helps Answer That Question
- Virginia Department of General Services Issues Final report on Statute of Limitations Exemption for State Construction Contracts
- Right to Work Laws and What a Potential Repeal Could Mean
- Construction Year in Review: 2019 Trends and What to Expect in 2020
- Department of General Services Conducts “Town Hall” on Statute of Limitations Bill
- New Virginia Supreme Court Case Refocuses Attention on Commonwealth's Immunity from Statutes of Limitation
- Virginia Department of General Services Releases Survey on Statute of Limitations Issue
- Workforce Development
- Dispute Resolution
- Government Contracts
- Little Miller Act
- Miller Act
- Mechanic's Liens
- Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA)
- Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation (DPOR)
- Virginia Employment Commission (VEC)
- Virginia Workers' Compensation Commission
- Uniform Statewide Building Code
- Change Orders
- February 2020
- January 2020
- November 2019
- August 2019
- June 2019
- April 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016